Cruise Price Traps EXPOSED! How Cruise Lines Get You to Spend More (and How to Beat Them)
By Adam & Mary — Hollett’s At Sea
Think your cruise fare is the total cost? Think again. The ticket is just the bait—the real money is what many cruisers spend onboard. In this guide, we’ll show you the most common psychology-powered spending traps at sea—and exactly how to outsmart each one.
Why this matters: Industry data shows the average guest spends hundreds in extras per cruise, and a large share of cruise-line revenue now comes from onboard purchases.124
Where Cruise Lines Really Make Money
- Base fares often cover the voyage itself; the profit engine is what you buy onboard (drinks, Wi-Fi, dining, spa, excursions, shops). Public filings show “onboard and other” was ~34% of Carnival Corp’s total revenue in 2024.4
- Average onboard spend: The Hustle estimated roughly $650 per passenger in upsells and onboard purchases.1
- Drinks are huge: Beverage programs account for about one-third of onboard revenue in many programs.2
- The airline-style model: Low entry price, then à-la-carte everything—Business Insider documented rising package prices (e.g., MSC drink packages up to +36% in recent years; NCL Premium Plus around $138/day + 20% gratuity, depending on sailing and market).3
Psychological Tricks They Use (and How to Beat Each One)
| 💡 Trick | What You’ll See | How to Beat It |
|---|---|---|
| Anchoring7 | A sky-high “Premium/Ultimate” option makes the mid-tier feel cheap. | Price your actual usage. The “middle” choice isn’t automatically good value. |
| Decoy Effect7 | A clearly bad option exists mainly to make another plan look great. | Ask: “Would I buy this without a bundle?” If not, skip it. |
| Scarcity & Urgency8 | “Sale ends at midnight!” countdowns and limited-time banners. | Don’t rush. Re-check tomorrow—promos often cycle back. |
| Drip Pricing | Low base price; fees & add-ons (gratuities, Wi-Fi tiers, water) appear later. | Read package terms before you buy; total the all-in cost. |
| “All-You-Can-Drink” Illusion | You buy more capacity than you’ll actually use. | Track drinks on day 1–2 and compare to à-la-carte prices (or use our calculator below). |
| Reciprocity | Free samples (spa, tastings) nudge you to upgrade. | Enjoy the sample. Smile. Walk away. |
💳 The “Invisible Money” Trick: Tap to Spend
On most ships, your keycard/medallion is your wallet. That removes the sting of payment, a well-studied effect: people spend more when the payment feels less “painful.” In classic experiments, participants bid up to twice as much when paying by credit card vs. cash; related research shows “decoupling” payment from consumption weakens the pain of paying.56
Beat it: Check your balance daily in the app or kiosk, set a spending cap, and mentally treat each tap like cash.21
Drink Package Math (The Industry’s Favorite Game)
- Prices vary by ship/date. Business Insider highlighted NCL’s high-tier pricing (~$138/day + 20% gratuity) and recent MSC increases (up to +36%), illustrating broad upward trends.3
- Break-even reality: Many cruisers need about 6–8 drinks/day (every day) to “win.” Royal Caribbean Blog pegs break-even typically around 6–7, depending on mix and prices.16
- Caps & exclusions: Packages often include drinks up to a price cap (e.g., Royal’s Deluxe covers items up to $14 per drink; higher-priced items incur the difference).17
Pro move: Use our Cruise Drink Package Calculator to model your actual habits before you buy.
Beyond the Bar: Common Onboard Upsells
- Specialty dining: Expect roughly $45–$75+ per person depending on venue/line. Example: Carnival Steakhouse lists $57.82 per person (incl. 18% service).19
- Spas: Excellent treatments—but post-massage product pitches are common. It’s OK to say no.22
- Wi-Fi tiers: Standard vs. “Premium/Streaming.” Unless you truly need HD streaming or uploads, the cheaper tier often suffices; Carnival explicitly advertises up to 15% off if you pre-purchase online.10
- Excursions: Ship tours are convenient but not always cheapest. Research reputable third-party operators and DIY options to compare.9
- Onboard “duty-free” shops: “Duty-free” ≠ automatic bargain; compare prices before you buy.18
Gratuities & “Forgotten” Fees
- Daily gratuities (auto-added): Royal Caribbean currently lists $18.50 (standard) and $21.00 (suites) per person per day.11 Norwegian’s service charge ranges roughly $20–$25 depending on stateroom/itinerary.12
- Wine policies (BYO): Typical allowances at embarkation (policies vary; corkage may apply): Royal Caribbean (1×750ml per adult), Carnival (1×750ml per adult), Celebrity (1×750ml per adult).131415
Beat the System: Smart Money Moves at Sea
- Set a spending cap in the app or at Guest Services; review your balance daily (Carnival’s kiosks make this easy).21
- Pre-purchase packages (drinks, Wi-Fi, dining, spa) when discounted; Carnival advertises up to 15% off online for Wi-Fi.10
- Re-price before you sail: On Royal Caribbean, you can cancel and repurchase Cruise Planner items if they go on sale pre-cruise.20
- Try à-la-carte first: Buy day-one drinks individually; if you’re trending toward package break-even, upgrade later (terms vary by line).
- Bring your own allowed wine (see policies above) and reusable water bottle.
- Skip FOMO tables (“70% off today only!”) unless you’ve price-checked.
- Max out the free stuff: Included shows, comedy, trivia, movies, main dining room, pizza, soft-serve, pools, and more.
Free Tools & Next Steps
- 🔢 Cruise Drink Package Calculator — run your numbers before you buy.
- 🧳 Free Cruise Packing List — don’t pay onboard for forgotten essentials.
- 🧭 Want personal help planning? I’m a travel advisor — request a cruise quote and I’ll hunt the best value for your dates and budget.
Watch Next
Sources
- The Hustle — “The economics of cruise ships.” [The Hustle]
- SevenFiftyDaily — “Cruise Ship Beverage Programs Are Booming.” [SevenFifty Daily]
- Business Insider (2023/2025 coverage of cruise pricing trends, MSC & NCL examples). [Business Insider]
- Carnival Corp. & plc — FY2024 Form 10-K (“Onboard and other” revenue ~34%). [Cruise Critic]
- Prelec & Simester (2001) — “Always Leave Home Without It? The Hidden Cost of Credit.” [SpringerLink]
- Prelec & Loewenstein (1998) — “The Red and the Black: Mental Accounting of Savings and Debt.” [INFORMS Pubs Online]
- Huber, Payne & Puto (1982) — Decoy (asymmetric dominance) effect. [Duke People]
- Banerjee et al. (2025) — Systematic review on tech-mediated scarcity messages/countdowns. [White Rose Research Online]
- Cruise Critic — “Independent Excursions vs. Ship Tours.” [Cruzely.com]
- Carnival — Internet Plans (pre-purchase up to 15% off onboard price). [Carnival Cruise Line]
- Royal Caribbean — Gratuities policy ($18.50 standard; $21 suites). [Royal Caribbean]
- Norwegian — Daily Service Charge (policy details). [FlyerTalk]
- Royal Caribbean — Alcohol policy (1×750 ml wine/champagne per adult at embarkation). [Royal Caribbean]
- Carnival — Liquor & beverage policy (1×750 ml wine/champagne per adult; corkage may apply). [Carnival Cruise Line]
- Celebrity — On-board FAQs (wine allowance). [Celebrity Cruises]
- Royal Caribbean Blog — Drink package break-even typically ~6–7 drinks/day (analysis). [Reddit]
- Royal Caribbean — Deluxe Beverage Package PDF (per-drink cap $14; exclusions). [Royal Caribbean]
- Cruise Critic — Duty-Free Shopping on Cruises (not always the cheapest). [Cruise Critic]
- Carnival — “For Your Eating Pleasure” (steakhouse pricing example). [Carnival Cruise Line]
- Royal Caribbean — Cruise Planner purchase terms (cancel & refund pre-cruise). [SciSpace]
- Carnival — Sail & Sign Kiosk (check balance, set limits, make payments). [Carnival Cruise Line]
- Condé Nast Traveler — Cruise ship spa tips & etiquette (expect product pitches). [Norwegian Cruise Line]
